FOB vs CIF: Which Should You Use When Importing Carpets from China?
Under FOB (Free on Board) Tianjin, the factory pays to get your carpets loaded onto the ship and you pay ocean freight, insurance and everything after; under CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight), the seller also pays freight and basic insurance to your destination port. In both cases the risk passes to you once the goods are on board in China, so the real choice is about who controls the freight booking and how transparent the total landed cost is.
You've seen both terms on every factory quotation, and the confusion between them costs buyers money. Below is a clear explanation with a worked, line-by-line landed-cost example so you know exactly which one to ask for.
Key Takeaways
- Under Incoterms 2020, risk transfers from seller to buyer when the goods are loaded on board the vessel at the port of shipment for both FOB and CIF.
- A CIF price includes ocean freight and minimum insurance to your port, but destination port charges, customs broker fees, duty, sales taxes and inland delivery are still paid by the buyer.
- On a 500 sqm printed-carpet order, a FOB Tianjin price of $3.00/sqm compares to a CIF Vancouver price of $3.60/sqm, and the total landed cost of the two ends up in a similar range once every line item is counted.
- Sea freight from Tianjin to Vancouver typically adds about $0.40-0.60/sqm for printed carpets, and cargo insurance typically costs 0.2-0.5% of cargo value.
- Always request both FOB and CIF quotes and compare total landed cost, not the headline price per square metre.
๐ฆ FOB โ Free on Board
Factory delivers goods on board the ship at Tianjin port. You pay freight and insurance from there.
- โ Product, export clearance and loading included
- โ You (or your forwarder) book sea freight
- โ You arrange insurance
- โ You handle customs clearance at destination
- โ Lower quoted price โ but more coordination for you
๐ข CIF โ Cost, Insurance, Freight
Seller arranges and pays shipping and basic insurance to your destination port.
- โ Product + freight to your port included
- โ Minimum insurance included
- โ You handle customs clearance at destination
- โ Higher quoted price โ but simpler for you
- โ Destination charges are still yours to pay
Who Pays What Under Incoterms 2020
FOB and CIF are defined by the International Chamber of Commerce in Incoterms 2020. Both are "sea and inland waterway" terms, and the key point most buyers miss is that risk transfers at the same moment under both: when the carpets are on board the vessel in Tianjin. If a container is damaged at sea under CIF, it is your loss to claim โ the seller's insurance policy just gives you something to claim against.
| Cost or responsibility | FOB Tianjin | CIF destination port |
|---|---|---|
| Production, packing, export cartons | Seller | Seller |
| Trucking to Tianjin port, export customs clearance | Seller | Seller |
| Origin terminal handling and loading on board | Seller | Seller |
| Risk of loss or damage after loading | Buyer | Buyer |
| Ocean freight to destination port | Buyer | Seller |
| Marine cargo insurance | Buyer (optional but wise) | Seller (minimum cover) |
| Destination terminal handling, delivery order fees | Buyer | Buyer |
| Import customs clearance, duty and taxes | Buyer | Buyer |
| Inland delivery to your warehouse | Buyer | Buyer |
Under CIF the seller only has to buy minimum insurance cover (Institute Cargo Clauses C, at 110% of the contract value). That covers major events such as sinking or fire but not many everyday causes of damage, like water ingress or handling damage. If you need broader "all risks" cover, ask for it in writing or buy your own policy.
Real Example: Printed Carpets from Tianjin to Vancouver
Here is the same order priced both ways, using typical figures from our guide to importing carpets from China. All amounts are USD and approximate; your own quote will differ by season, volume and port.
Scenario: 500 sqm printed carpets, shipped to Vancouver
| Line item | FOB Tianjin ($3.00/sqm) | CIF Vancouver ($3.60/sqm) |
|---|---|---|
| Goods (500 sqm) | $1,500 | $1,800 (includes freight and insurance) |
| Sea freight Tianjin โ Vancouver ($0.40-0.60/sqm) | $200-300 | Included |
| Cargo insurance (0.2-0.5% of value) | Under $10 | Included (minimum cover) |
| Destination port handling & documents ($0.05-0.10/sqm) | $25-50 | $25-50 |
| Canadian duty (~8%, assessed on the goods' value) | ~$120 | ~$120 |
| Customs broker fee | $200-500 | $200-500 |
| Delivery to warehouse ($0.15-0.25/sqm) | $75-125 | $75-125 |
| Total before GST/HST | ~$2,130-2,600 | ~$2,220-2,600 |
GST/HST (5-13% depending on province) is charged on top at import. GST-registered businesses can generally recover it as an input tax credit, so it affects cash flow more than final margin.
Two things to notice in this example. First, duty in Canada (and generally in the US and Australia) is assessed on the transaction value of the goods excluding international freight, so switching to CIF does not reduce your duty bill โ check how your own country values imports with your broker. Second, on a small shipment the fixed fees (broker, documents) are a large share of the total, which is one reason consolidating designs into one shipment lowers your landed cost per square metre.
Why CIF Can Hide Freight Markup
CIF is convenient, but it is not always transparent. Because the seller books the freight, you rarely see what they actually paid the shipping line. Common patterns to watch for:
- Freight margin built into the unit price. If the CIFโFOB difference is well above current market freight for your volume, the extra is margin, not shipping.
- "Cheap CIF, expensive arrival." Some seller-nominated forwarders quote low ocean freight and recover it through high destination charges (handling, documentation, delivery order fees) billed to you on arrival.
- Minimum insurance only. CIF only requires basic cover; a damaged pallet may not be covered at all.
- Less control over timing. The seller chooses the carrier, sailing and transit route โ which matters before peak seasons such as Chinese New Year.
None of this means CIF is a bad choice. It means you should ask the seller to show the freight portion separately and get an estimate of destination charges before you agree.
When FOB Makes Sense
- You have an in-house logistics team or a freight forwarder experienced with Chinese imports
- You're shipping full containers and can negotiate better freight rates than the seller
- You consolidate goods from several suppliers into one shipment
- You want to choose the carrier, transit time and insurance level yourself
- You have existing relationships with customs brokers
When CIF Makes Sense
- You're new to importing from China
- You don't have a freight forwarder yet
- You want one simple delivered-to-port price to compare quotes
- Your order is small (LCL) and you don't want to manage a booking yourself
What to Ask a Freight Forwarder (FOB)
If you choose FOB, your forwarder becomes your most important logistics partner. When requesting a quote, send the cargo details (cartons, gross weight, cubic metres, pickup at Tianjin/Xingang) and ask:
- Is the quote all-in from FOB Tianjin to my warehouse, or port-to-port only?
- What destination charges (terminal handling, documentation, delivery order, devanning for LCL) are included, and which are extra?
- Is customs brokerage included, and is the broker experienced with textiles and floor coverings?
- What is the routing and estimated transit time, and is it a direct sailing or transshipment?
- What insurance do you offer, at what premium, and on what clauses (all risks or basic)?
- What are your rates for a 20ft container versus LCL at my volume?
Get two or three forwarder quotes against the same cargo details and compare them with the seller's CIF price. That comparison tells you instantly whether the CIF freight is fair.
How to Ask for FOB and CIF Quotes
When you request a quote, always ask for both FOB and CIF prices. A reputable supplier will give you both without hesitation. For CIF to Canada, the main destination ports are Vancouver and Prince Rupert on the west coast; Toronto and Montreal-area deliveries usually continue by rail from the west coast or arrive via eastern ports, which adds roughly $0.10-0.20/sqm. For Vancouver, budget about $0.40-0.60/sqm for sea freight on printed carpets.
A good quote request includes product type, size mix, quantity per design, destination port or city, and whether you want insurance. Before shipping, it is worth booking a pre-shipment quality inspection, because once the goods are loaded the risk is yours under either term.
I always provide both FOB and CIF quotes so Canadian buyers can compare the true total landed cost. Request a free quote below.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does FOB mean when buying carpets from China?
FOB (Free on Board) Tianjin means the seller packs the carpets, clears Chinese export customs and loads them on board the vessel at Tianjin port. From that moment the buyer owns the risk and pays ocean freight, insurance, destination port charges, import customs clearance, duty and taxes, and delivery to the warehouse.
What is CIF and how does it differ from FOB?
CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) means the seller also pays ocean freight and minimum insurance to the named destination port, such as Vancouver. Under Incoterms 2020 the risk still transfers to the buyer when the goods are loaded on board in China, exactly as with FOB. The buyer still pays destination port charges, customs clearance, duty, taxes and inland delivery.
Which is better for Canadian buyers, FOB or CIF?
CIF is simpler for first-time importers and small shipments because the seller books the freight and you get one delivered-to-port price. FOB gives you control over the carrier, transit time, insurance and freight cost, which experienced importers with their own freight forwarder usually prefer. In a worked 500 sqm printed-carpet example to Vancouver, total landed cost ended up in a similar range under both terms.
What hidden costs should I watch for with CIF quotes?
CIF quotes exclude destination port handling and documentation fees (around $0.05-0.10/sqm), customs broker fees, import duty (about 8% for most carpets entering Canada), GST/HST and inland trucking (around $0.15-0.25/sqm). Also watch for freight margin built into the unit price and for seller-nominated forwarders who quote low freight but charge high destination fees on arrival.
Does CIF include insurance that fully covers my carpets?
Not necessarily. Under Incoterms 2020 CIF only requires minimum cover (Institute Cargo Clauses C at 110% of contract value), which covers major events such as sinking or fire but not many common causes of damage. Ask the seller for all-risks cover in writing or buy your own policy, which typically costs 0.2-0.5% of cargo value.
How do I calculate total landed cost for carpets from China?
Start with the FOB price, then add sea freight (about $0.40-0.60/sqm from Tianjin to Vancouver for printed carpet), insurance, destination port handling, customs duty, the customs broker fee and delivery to your warehouse, then add GST/HST. For a CIF price, start from the CIF figure and add everything except freight and insurance. Confirm current duty rates with your customs broker.
Want FOB and CIF quotes for your carpet order? I'll get you both prices from verified Tianjin factories within 48 hours.
๐ฉ Get a Free Quote โ